Predestination is a dirty word. Kind of.
This is because, if this phrase pops up in conversation, it usually refers to an abhorrent idea: When God creates human beings, God predestines many for hell and only some for heaven. And it is only because of God’s freedom, goodness, and grace that these few are saved. So, how one lives one’s life doesn’t matter. Everything has already been decided before anyone was born and therefore is part of God’s eternal and flawless design.
This idea is technically known as “double predestination.” Although one version or another of this idea has been around since early Christianity, its most lasting articulation, and the one with which we in the United States still must grapple from time to time, is based in how sections of John Calvin’s Institutes of the Christian Religion are interpreted.
To its credit, this is not what the Catholic Church teaches. The Catholic Church teaches a kind of “single predestination” in which God predestines all of God’s creatures for one destination: full communion with God, aka heaven. The technical term is rarely used, but the idea abides.
The rub is this: For some reason (and the exact reason has been an object of theological speculation for centuries), God respects human free will. The infinite, triune Creator respects the choices of God’s beloved finite creatures and calls us to be cocreators in sync with God’s spirit among us. And God’s spirit desires for us to choose life for ourselves, others, and all of creation—the twin commands of love of God and love of neighbor. As Jesus personifies God’s will in John’s gospel: “A thief comes only to steal and slaughter and destroy; I came so that they might have life and have it more abundantly” (10:10).
When we choose poorly and cause harm “in our thoughts and in our words, in what we have done and in what we have failed to do,” God neither condemns nor abandons us. God doubles down on belovedness. God still offers us a pathway to full communion—one that will never be closed to us, because it is the one we are destined for.
If nothing else, we must realize that predestination is not a question about humankind, heaven, or hell; instead, it is a question about who God is. This is why, for Catholics, no one ever has been or ever will be predestined to hell. The reason is simple. Any God who creates a beloved creature and assigns them an ultimate destiny of eternal torture, no matter how they live their life, is not a God worth worshipping. And that deity cannot be reconciled with the God revealed through Jesus Christ. Jesus’ entire self was grounded in the loving Father about whom Jesus taught, through whom Jesus lived, and with whom Jesus still dwells. And that good parent desires only one thing: eternal, beloved relationship with God’s children as part of a cosmic beloved community.
This article also appears in the November 2026 issue of U.S. Catholic (Vol. 91, No. 11, page 48). Click here to subscribe to the magazine.
Image: Unsplash











