Still from Obsession

‘Obsession’ is a horror story about love becoming idolatry

‘Obsession’ doesn't say a lot about incels, but it does give deep insight into the role of idols and icons in our romantic culture.
Arts & Culture

When I began teaching high schoolers this semester, I found myself pleas­antly surprised by the invitation to lead several sections of a class on sacramental theology. Throughout the course, my students and I have discussed various theological topics such as the Holy Trinity, grace, sacramentality, and the incarnation. But something that returns week after week in our classroom discussions is the nature of divine and human love. My students were amazed to learn that Greek—the language in which the New Testament was written—has several different words for love, including storgē (familial), agape (self-­giving), philautia (self-love), pragma (committed), ludus (casual/uncommitted), philia (friendship), eros (passionate/sexual), and mania (obsessive).

Curry Barker’s Obsession—a low-budget horror film that surprisingly became one of the highest-­grossing films of 2026—is not a film about agape, pragma, eros, or even ludus. Rather, it explores the Greek concept of mania: a destructive attachment rooted in extreme possessiveness, jealousy, and a profound fear of rejection or abandonment. The film follows protagonist Baron “Bear” Bailey (Michael Johnston) and his unre­quited affection for his friend and coworker Nikki Freeman (Inde Navarrette). After obtaining a novelty toy called a “One Wish Willow” from a local crystal shop, Bear wishes that Nikki would love him more than anyone else in the entire world.

What follows from this wish is a terrifying escalation of actions by the now-possessed Nikki, which inevitably leads to severe psychosis and, eventually, murder. Bear’s entitlement and initial obsession with Nikki—which results in a twisted post-wish reality whereby Bear’s desires become Nikki’s—can be understood through French philosopher and theologian Jean-Luc Marion’s phenomenological framework of the idol and icon.

Marion writes that the idol reflects our gaze, acting as an extension of our innermost desires that arrests our vision and mirrors back our own thoughts, feelings, and projections. Because idols are entirely dependent on the very gazes they satisfy, it is the viewer that grants the idol its power. However, by attempting to force the object of our desire into our own fixed constructs, we become idolaters who believe we have achieved mastery over the other, blinding us from ever looking beyond a superficial image. In the film, Bear’s wish literally transfigures Nikki into a living, breathing idol—a reflection of his own ego and manufactured desires that strips her of true agency and reduces her to an object of consumption.

Advertisement

On the other hand, the icon opens up the viewer to a transcendent reality of the other in their true alterity (otherness), inviting a reciprocal, nonpossessive relationship built on reverence and surrender. In this sense, the icon reverses one’s gaze by acting like a window that allows the infinite and the divine to shine through, opening our eyes to a depth that surpasses surface-level understandings.

Contemporary culture’s approach to dating and relationships is governed by the logic of the idol. Pop psychologists on TikTok and Instagram, along with self-credentialed relationship coaches, say that romantic relationships exist solely for personal gratification and happiness. They are about satisfying our lustful gaze through the art of acquisition—whether that be the acquisition of another’s time, money, attention, or body. If a relationship results in inconvenience, is fraught with struggle and challenge, or asks anything of us that remotely resembles sacrifice, it is to be thrown out and exchanged for something more manageable and convenient.

But sacramental love, which is where the reality of the icon resides, operates on an entirely different plane. It does not exist for self-gratification but purely for the good of the other—the one who is called the beloved. It does not adopt the gaze of one attempting to possess, grasp, or control; rather, it adopts a posture of reverence, ultimately respecting the freedom and alterity of the one being loved.

Perhaps what is most shocking, yet paradoxically beautiful, about this kind of love is that it is still capable of loving even when it is not loved in return. This is why the Bible says that the cross (our ultimate model of sacramental love) is a “stumbling block” and “foolishness to those who are perishing” (1 Cor. 1:18–25). Christ’s loving gaze toward a human­ity that hated and would ultimately crucify him defies all worldly logic. It is what the biblical text refers to as agape and kenosis: God’s total self-gift that expects nothing in return.

Advertisement

Bear’s sin is not his desire to be loved, for love comes from God and is holy. Rather, his sin is born out of a covetous desire to possess that which can only exist as a radical gift. Ultimately, his misplaced desires impact his ability to see and apprehend real­ity, resulting in a form of narcissism that infringes another’s freedom to choose.

Sadly, Bear’s gaze toward Nikki inadvertently bastardizes the icon of love into an idol; we see the full extent of this perversion in Nikki’s growing obses­sion with him. To love Nikki sacramentally (and, in turn, for her to love Bear in the post-wish reality) would mean to will the other’s ultimate good above all else, even when one’s own desires for companionship and union are in direct competition with the other’s freedom.

Something I fear may get lost in shallow reviews of this film that only see it as a critique of incel culture, whereby being nice entitles one to possess another, is that all of us at some point have been Bear. All of us have believed that we were entitled to something by virtue of our being (in our minds) honest, good, and pure.

It’s the classic case of the older brother in the parable of the prodigal son: Because we have been good and obedient, we believe we are entitled to things the father offers another as unmerited gift. Each of us at some point in our lives has become jealous, angry, possessive, and manipulative, declaring, “Listen! For all these years I have been working like a slave for you, and I have never disobeyed your command, yet you have never given me even a young goat so that I might celebrate with my friends. But when this son of yours came back, who has devoured your assets with prostitutes, you killed the fatted calf for him!” (Luke 15:29–30).

Advertisement

To make Bear the sole villain in this story is to fall into a kind of spiritual and moral hypocrisy that attempts to absolve us of the very behaviors natural to all of us. Obsession is less a commentary on which gender is more culpable for the rise of incel culture, and more a cautionary tale about desire and the ways that it shapes our moral and religious imaginations to the point of absolute corruption.

It also serves as a stark portrayal of what love is not: a narcissistic projection of our own fears and insecurities. Catholics are reminded that the true nature of love is sacramental, coming from God as a gratuitous gift of grace.


This article also appears in the November 2026 issue of U.S. Catholic (Vol. 91, No. 11, pages 18-19). Click here to subscribe to the magazine.

Image: Courtesy of Focus Features / © 2026 FOCUS FEATURES LLC

Advertisement
ad promoting donations to Friends of U.S. Catholic journalism

About the author

LaRyssa D. Herrington

LaRyssa D. Herrington is an independent researcher and scholar with a doctorate degree in systematic theology and liturgical studies from the University of Notre Dame. Being the author of several peer-reviewed articles and two book chapters, Herrington's research has also been featured in popular press outlets such as the National Catholic Reporter, The Just Word (Future Church), Religion News Service, the National Black Catholic Congress, the Black Catholic Messenger, and the Glad You Asked and Looking for Drinkable Water podcasts. A lifelong participant in the performing and cultural arts, Herrington's academic interests converge with her passions for the theatre, spoken word, writing, singing, playing instruments, and performing solo or with various ensembles.